Scenario
A client requests a process capability report, asking for Cpk ≥ 1.33. You submit it, and the client replies, asking: "Are you providing Cpk or Ppk? We require both." You're stunned—aren't they the same thing?
No, they are not, and the difference is significant.
Key Difference: How σ is Calculated
Cp / Cpk use short-term within-subgroup variation
σ is estimated from the subgroup range (R-bar) or standard deviation (S-bar).
Pp / Ppk use long-term overall variation
σ is calculated directly from the standard deviation of all data.
In plain terms:
- Cp/Cpk = How well you *can* do under stable conditions (potential capability)
- Pp/Ppk = How well you *actually* do, including batch-to-batch differences, shift changes, and time drift.
Relationship Between Values
Typically: Cpk > Ppk
This is because Cp only considers small variations within subgroups, whereas Pp includes all variations (including batch-to-batch and time trends).
If there's a significant difference between Cpk and Ppk (e.g., Cpk = 1.5, Ppk = 0.9), it indicates:
- The process itself has good precision (short-term stability).
- But there are long-term drift or batch-to-batch variation issues.
- You need to address these through batch management, shift consistency, and equipment maintenance.
When to Use Which
| Situation | Use Which |
|---|---|
| Initial evaluation of a new process (only a few batches of data) | Pp / Ppk |
| Capability confirmation after process stabilization | Cp / Cpk |
| Long-term client reports | Both are required |
| Comparison before and after process improvement | Pp / Ppk (reflects true improvement magnitude) |
| Control charts show process stability | Cp / Cpk is more meaningful |
Formula Comparison
| Index | Formula | σ Source |
|---|---|---|
| Cp | (USL - LSL) / 6σ̂ | R-bar / d₂ or S-bar / c₄ |
| Cpk | min[(USL-μ)/3σ̂, (μ-LSL)/3σ̂] | Same as above |
| Pp | (USL - LSL) / 6s | Standard deviation s of all data |
| Ppk | min[(USL-μ)/3s, (μ-LSL)/3s] | Same as above |
Golden Rule
"Cpk is your best state, Ppk is your true performance. Clients buy Ppk, not your potential."